Home/News/Wedge Wire Alloy Selection: Abrasion or Corrosion First? | ERQI WIRE
Wedge Wire Alloy Selection: Abrasion or Corrosion First? | ERQI WIRE
Seven alloys get quoted for wedge wire screens and they are not on one scale. Two questions decide almost every case: is there chloride, and is the duty abrasive. A working decision tree with the numbers behind it.
Seven alloys get quoted for wedge wire screens, and buyers often line them up as if they sat on one scale from cheap to good. They do not. They sit on two different scales — resistance to corrosion, and resistance to wear — and the alloys that win on one frequently lose on the other. Almost every expensive mistake in screen material selection comes from optimising the wrong scale.
Two questions, in this order
First: is there chloride, or acid, in the medium? Not “is it wet” and not “is it dirty” — specifically chloride ions, or free acid. This question decides the corrosion family and it comes first because a screen that pits through in six months never gets to show how well it resisted abrasion.
Second: is the duty abrasive? Dry ore, coal, sand, slag, scale. This decides the wear family, and it only matters once the corrosion question has been answered.
If both answers are “yes”, you are in the expensive corner: chloride plus abrasion means duplex at minimum, and the choice between 2205 and 2507 is then a temperature question. If both are “no”, 304 is the honest answer and anything more is donation.
The corrosion family: PREN does the ranking
Pitting resistance equivalent number, PREN = %Cr + 3.3×%Mo + 16×%N, ranks the stainless and duplex grades on chloride duty.
| Alloy | PREN | Chloride limit, roughly |
|---|---|---|
| 304 / 304L | ~18 | Fresh water only; pits in any real chloride |
| 316L | ~25 | Mild chloride, near ambient, no stagnation |
| 2205 | ~35 | Chloride water to about 60 °C, moderate concentration |
| 2507 | ~43 | Hot brine, high chloride, stagnant seawater between cycles |
| C276 | not applicable | Wet chlorine, hypochlorite, mixed acid — outside the stainless scale |
C276 does not have a useful PREN because it is not a stainless steel passivating on chromium alone; it is a nickel-molybdenum alloy that holds in both oxidising and reducing acids. Rank it separately, and only reach for it when the medium contains chlorine species or acid that would attack duplex. The C276 wedge wire page has the environment list.
The wear family: manganese and nitrogen instead of nickel
The two high-manganese grades are the ones most often misunderstood, because they are cheap and buyers assume cheap means weak.
202B is 12Cr18Mn8Ni5N, UNS S35450, the Chinese-standard equivalent of ASTM 202. Manganese at 8–10 % and nitrogen at 0.2–0.3 % hold the austenitic structure with only 4.5–6 % nickel. It runs at roughly 80 % of the price of 304 and wears noticeably better, because its work-hardening rate is higher.
809C, also sold as E200, is 10Cr21Mn16NiN: about 17 % manganese, 1.5 % nickel, 0.6 % nitrogen. It is fully non-magnetic, work-hardens harder than anything else on this list, and costs less than 202B. On coal and ore screening it routinely outlasts 304 by three times or more. The full chemistry and the welding caveats are in the 809C and 202B article.
The two counter-intuitive results
In abrasive duty, the more corrosion-resistant alloy is often the more expensive mistake. A mine that specifies 316L for a coal dewatering deck pays about 1.6 times the price of 809C and typically gets a third of the wear life, because 316L is soft and 809C work-hardens under the slurry. The screen is not failing from corrosion — there is no chloride in the water — it is failing from erosion of the slot edges. Paying for corrosion resistance the duty cannot use is the most common form of waste in this table.
In chloride duty, the cheaper alloy costs more by the end of the year. A coastal plant that substitutes 202B for 316L saves perhaps 20 % on the first order. With 1.5 % nickel and manganese sulphide inclusions as pitting initiation sites, it will have pitted through at the weld within a season, and the replacement plus the downtime lands well past the saving. Cheap alloys are cheap in the applications they were designed for.
What to send with an enquiry
Four numbers decide the alloy and the slot together: the medium (what is in the water), the chloride level (ppm, or “seawater”), the temperature, and the abrasive content (what solids pass over the screen and how fast). Add the slot you need and the flow, and a quotation can be firm on the first pass.
All seven alloys are available as wire and as support bars, and they must be matched — the support bar material page explains why a mixed-alloy screen fails at the weld. The constructions themselves are under wedge wire. Send the four numbers and we will name the alloy rather than the price list.
More from ERQI
-
Technical
809C and 202B: The High-Manganese Alloys Behind Wear Screens | ERQI WIRE
809C (10Cr21Mn16NiN) and 202B (12Cr18Mn8Ni5N) replace nickel with manganese and nitrogen. Why that makes them hard, non-magnetic and cheap, and where the trade stops working.
-
Technical
Wedge Wire, Profile Wire, Shaped Wire: How the Three Names Relate | ERQI WIRE
Three names get used for the same drawn section depending on which industry is buying it. What each name actually means, why buyers pick different words, and how to write an enquiry that works in all three.
-
Business
Small-Batch Custom Shaped Wire: When It Pays | ERQI WIRE
A small batch of custom shaped wire carries the same tooling as a big one. When the arithmetic still works: machined-part replacement, downtime cost, design validation - and when it does not.
Ready to start your project?
Send us your drawing or sample — we reply within 24 hours on working days.